Article: Berkeley Admissions Demystified

Following the theme of transparency in MBA admissions (see last week’s blog entries), we’d like to draw your attention to the most recent edition of Berkeley’s MBA E-News. The December edition of this newsletter has an informative explanation of the admissions process at Berkeley, describing the reading process. Here are a few key of the key points:

1) Applications are reviewed in random order.
2) All applications get a minimum of two reviews.
3) If the first two reviews both get a ‘thumbs down’, the applicant is rejected.
4) Applicants who make it past a third read are invited to interview.
5) Interviews are conducted on campus by students or off campus by alumni interviewers.
6) Following the interview, a file is reviewed again at an admissions committee meeting.

For the full text of the article: http://www.haas.berkeley.edu/MBA/enews/dec04/story1.html

Share

Article: Good News For Indian Applicants?

The India Daily has published an interesting article covering GMAT trends amongst Indian test takers. Citing a study conducted by the Graduate Management Admissions Council, the article notes that the number of students taking the test in India has dropped off dramatically in the last two years (by 16% last season and as much as 25% this year). The author explains this trend as follows:

1) More Indian students are taking the CAT (Common Admissions Test) instead of the GMAT. This test enables them to apply to several top business programs offered in India – but is not valid for US and European MBA programs.

2) Programs offered in India are inexpensive when compared to options in Europe and America.

3) MBA options in India are improving – along with the types of jobs that come with the degree.

This is potentially good news for those Indians who are looking to go to the US or Europe for their MBA, since the applicant pool at top MBA programs has been virtually saturated with Indian engineers in recent years (especially those in the field of IT). Of course, despite the lower GMAT volume reported in the article, the Clear Admit team has seen no evidence of fewer Indian applicants in the admissions pool just yet…

For the full text of the article:
http://www.indiadaily.com/breaking_news/15449.asp

Share

Admissions Info: decisions, volume and more…

Last week was an exciting week with numerous admits going out for Darden (EA) and Columbia (ED). We also saw interview invitations mailed to Stanford and MIT R1 applicants and continued to receive ‘field reports’ from applicants completing their Wharton and HBS interviews.

Despite all of the activity last week, this week looks to be even more charged with news. As usual, our clients have been updating us with their results. The BusinessWeek discussion forums have also been flooded with noteworthy developments. Yesterday, Tuck (EA) began calling applicants with good news (admit calls will continue to go out through the end of the week). Kellogg also began notifying a handful of R1 applicants who have made the cut. Meanwhile, Stanford interviews continued to trickle out and UNC sent an email to all ‘early action’ applicants reminding them that decisions will be released on December 13th.

On other fronts, several applicants offered their predictions with regards to applicant volume. From our standpoint, despite a slight up-tick in application volume for Wharton’s first round (+2%), we’re betting on declining numbers at several top schools before the season is over. With GMAT test-taker volume lagging last year’s figures, this seems inevitable.

Speaking of Wharton, for those of you anxiously awaiting the December 23rd R1 notification date, there is a slight chance that you won’t have to wait that long. In prior years, the school has often pushed up the notification date (sometimes by as much as one week). If this happens, the adcom will typically notify everyone of the change via the student2student discussion forums. If we had to guess on an ‘early release’ date, we’d go with the 16th or the 21st of December…

Hang in there everyone! More news to come…

Share

Article: The State of Writing in Corporate America

The New York Times has published an interesting piece on the lack of writing skills in corporate America and the amount of money that firms are spending on remedial training for their employees. This article should give MBA applicants a sense for what admissions officers often have to put up with when they read applications. It should also explain why admissions officers really appreciate coherent essays that respond to the questions and demonstrate a healthy amount of introspection.

For the full text of the article:
What Corporate America Can’t Build: A Sentence

In other news, one of our favorite bloggers has published a ‘Wharton R1 Countdown’ on his site. For those of you who enjoy watching the minutes tick off the clock, check out the site: http://hella.opencoder.org/. You will also want to note the links to the ‘blogs of blogs’ (nifty content aggregators) – one for current MBA applicants and one for current MBA students.

Share

Admissions Info: Top Schools Reaching Out?

This is certainly an exciting time of the year for admissions officers and applicants alike. Over the course of this young admissions season, we’ve seen more and more evidence of schools reaching out to applicants. Before we examine some of the new marketing developments at top MBA programs, let’s look at the data that appears to be driving these initiatives:

-HBS had 10,382 applications in 2001-2002, vs. 7,139 last season (a 31% drop)
-Wharton had 8,371 applications in 2001-2002, vs. 5,622 last season (a 32% drop)
-Stanford had 5,864 in 2001-2002, vs. 4,697 last season (a 20% decline)

It’s clear that the last two years have been a bit lean, although the volume reported last season is not terribly far from data in the late 90′s (suggesting a return to pre-bubble footing). Needless to say, evidence is mounting that the schools are back on the marketing offensive as they compete for a smaller group of elite applicants:

Harvard
Traditionally, the Harvard admissions process has been described as a ‘black box’, where only a small team of admissions officers call the shots ‘behind closed doors’. This year, in somewhat of a break with tradition, HBS organized a “Round 1 Conference Call” for applicants. The conference call featured admissions officers and HBS students, sharing data about interview invitations and answering questions about the program. During the conference call, the admissions team offered the following statistics: 250 R1 interviews have been conducted thus far, 700 R1 interviews will be offered in total. The school will interview roughly 1500 applicants across all three rounds, resulting in roughly 1000 offers of admission (i.e. 66% of those interviewed will get in). This sort of marketing activity is great news for applicants, since it allows everyone to get a better sense of the process (and takes some of the mystery/anxiety out of the waiting game).

Wharton
The Wharton school is the clear leader when it comes to using creative marketing techniques in the admissions office. The school’s policy of ‘admissions transparency’, coupled with lightning fast decision notification has sent somewhat of a shock through the system of MBA admissions at the top schools. Wharton applicants discuss the school via moderated discussion forums and read online diaries from current students. The fact that R1 Wharton applicants get their decisions before Christmas (but aren’t forced to decide until the spring) is another unique feature that helps Wharton stand out from other top schools. Of course, all of these initiatives have been on offer for the past two admissions seasons, so the school has been forced to innovate again this season in hopes of maintaining admissions volume. This year, applicants can get the latest tips and information from the Wharton admissions blog.

Stanford
Although Stanford has seen less of a decline in application volume than HBS or Wharton, the school has also made some interesting changes over the past few seasons. These changes include the introduction and expansion of an interviewing initiative (the school had previously skipped the interview process entirely). In addition, the program has introduced the Stanford Admissions Newsletter, offering admissions tips and addressing common questions that many applicants have. The highlight of this monthly newsletter is the Director’s Corner, where Derrick Bolton, Assistant Dean and Director of MBA Admissions, offers his take on subjects like essays and the interview process along with a healthy dose of admissions philosophy.

These kinds of changes are not limited to the schools mentioned above. In fact, Columbia’s ED round is viewed by some as a direct response to competition from peer schools (and a desire to manage yield). Of course, the binding nature of this early decision is always the source of controversy. Stay tuned to this blog for more content on this subject.

Share

Admissions Info: Columbia ED

The past week has been incredibly busy with interviews and interview invites (Stanford, HBS, Wharton, Columbia, etc.). We’ve also heard from many clients who received positive admissions news from programs like Columbia and Darden last week.

Here are a few of the emails that came in from our Columbia ED applicants:

—– Original Message —–
From: xxxxxxxxxx
To: Graham Richmond
Sent: Tuesday, November 30, 2004 4:20 PM
Subject: Good news from 116th and Broadway

Hi Graham,

I just got a note from Columbia — I got in! Tried calling you a few mins ago but couldn’t stop my hand from shaking! Very, very, very excited…just wanted to say thanks for your help. Thanks again!

-xxxxxx

—–Original Message—–
From: xxxxx
Sent: Friday, December 03, 2004 11:45 AM
To: Eliot Ingram
Subject: Re: Columbia?

Hi Eliot,

I was accepted at Columbia on Tuesday!!!

I can’t say enough about how helpful I found your advice during the entire process – from the essays to the interview. I plan to recommend your services to anyone that is serious about getting their MBA. The best part is I got into my top choice and don’t have to spend the holiday season writing more applications!

Best wishes and thanks again!

xxxxxx

—– Original Message —–
From: xxxxxx
To: Graham Richmond
Sent: Friday, December 03, 2004 11:22 PM
Subject: Re: CBS Interview

GRAHAM!

I got admitted to COLUMBIA!! I’m so happy! Thank you so much for all your help. :-) :-) :-)

xxxxxx

Congratulations to everyone who made the cut in Columbia’s ED round! Keep in mind that you have three weeks to accept the offer and put down your 5K deposit.

Finally, congratulations are also in order for blogger DirtyMartini, on her acceptance to Columbia as well! The Clear Admit team has enjoyed following your blog and we couldn’t be happier for you!

Share

Article: New Kings Of Capitalism

The Economist has published a special report on the field of Private Equity and its rise to prominence in the economy. This article is relevant to MBA applicants for two reasons:

1) More and more applicants express dreams of going into private equity after completing their MBA. Since many of these applicants have no prior work experience in the field, reading the report in the Economist should provide a very helpful overview.

2) For the rest of the applicant pool, this article should help demystify the world of private equity. Even if you intend to work in another field, it clearly makes sense to have a strong understanding of what all the fuss is about.

Finally, we’d also recommend this special report to admissions officers who are curious about this popular field. Along with social entrepreneurship, private equity-themed applicants are rising in numbers….

The New Kings of Capitalism: “In two decades, private-equity firms have moved from the outer fringe to the centre of the capitalist system. But, asks Matthew Bishop, can they keep it up?” http://www.economist.com/displaystory.cfm?story_id=3398496

Share

Admissions Info: Stanford R1 Update

As many of you know, Stanford has started offering interview invitations to R1 applicants. In the event that you are keeping score, the school’s numbers typically look like this:

Number of applicants: 4,696 (last year)
Number of interview invites: 1,000 – 1,250 (21-26% of the pool)
Number of admits: 400-500 (roughly 40% of those interviewed, or 9.6% of the applicant pool)

For those of you who are curious about the interview process itself, here’s the letter that goes out to applicants who are invited (Note: we’ve removed some information about ‘official transcripts’ for the sake of brevity):

From: Stanford MBA Admissions Office interview@gsb.stanford.edu
To:
CC: “interview@gsb.stanford.edu
Subject: Stanford MBA Program Interview
Date: Wed, 01 Dec 2004 21:47:09 GMT

Hello xxxxxx,

The Stanford MBA Admissions Office has reviewed your application to the Stanford MBA Program. We would like to invite you to meet with one of our alumni for a 45-minute interview. The purpose of this meeting is both evaluative and informational, with an emphasis on creating a positive and enjoyable experience.

Your alumni interviewer is: Name: xxxxxxxx, MBA – 19xx
E-mail: xxxx
Phone: xxx xxx xxxx
City: xxxxxxxx

If you have a pre-existing relationship with your alumni interviewer, please immediately contact Judy Low, Interview Coordinator, at +1 (650)>736-2034 or interview@gsb.stanford.edu so that we can reassign you.

To move forward, it is imperative that you follow the instructions below:

1. We ask that you contact your alumni interviewer – contact information is provided above – to schedule a mutually convenient time and location to meet. We suggest business attire, but ask that you contact your alumni interviewer to confirm specifics of the meeting.

2. Please send your alumni interviewer a copy of your resume via email or fax. Please do NOT send other information (your essays, transcripts, etc.).

3. If at all possible, please schedule and complete the interview within two weeks. If it is not feasible to complete the interview in that time period, please contact Judy Low, Interview Coordinator, at +1(650)736-2034 or interview@gsb.stanford.edu.

4. As soon as you have confirmed the date of your meeting, please send a reply email to interview@gsb.stanford.edu with that information. If you reschedule the meeting, please ensure that you send another email to interview@gsb.stanford.edu so that we are aware of the change.

We hope you will find the meeting stimulating and informative. Thank you again for your continued interest in the Stanford Graduate School of Business.

Best regards,
Judy Low
Interview Coordinator
Stanford MBA Admissions Office
interview@gsb.stanford.edu

In addition to the interview invites that have gone out, Stanford also sent out a general email to R1 applicants informing them that their file was complete and that the review process had begun. The email also indicated that the admissions office would be closed from December 20th – January 2nd.

For more information on Stanford interviews, check the FAQ on the Stanford web site and Derrick Bolton’s “Director’s Corner” entry from October. Also, check out the BW Forums for some relevant discussion on Stanford Interviews, etc.

Contact Clear Admit to learn more about our mock interview services and Stanford Interview Guide.

Share

Admissions Info: Harvard Business School R1 Update

There has been a lot of activity on the HBS front for ’round one’ applicants. Our clients have reported interview invites in numerous cities in the United States (East Coast, West Coast and Mid-west regions) as well locations across Europe, the Middle East and Asia. Despite intense speculation on the BW Discussion Boards, it would appear that invites are trickling out regardless of one’s location (as has traditionally been the case).

The school continues to use a variety of methods to conduct interviews:
1) Hub interviews at HBS Research Centers and other locations
2) On-campus interviews
3) Phone interviews
4) Alumni interviews

Yesterday, the HBS ‘admissions fog’ thickened when the school sent out the following e-mail:

> From: “MBA Admissions” admissevents@hbs.edu>
> To:
> CC:
> Subject: HBS Admissions – Round 1 Applicant Update
> Date: Tue, 30 Nov 2004 12:01:23 -0500

> Hello from Harvard Business School –

> MBA Admissions is inviting interested Round 1 applicants to participate in a web-enhanced conference call on Monday, December 6, 2004 from 12:00 – 1:00 pm (EST).

> Associate Director Patty Dowden will give an update on the admissions process while two students, Chris Crawford (’06) and Kelly Campbell (’05), will provide insight into current student activities.

> There will be time for participants to ask questions of Patty, Chris, and Kelly directly at the end of the update. Instructions for dialing into the conference call will be provided to all registrants via a confirmation email at the end of the week.

> Space is limited. In order to participate, you must register online by noon on Friday, December 3rd (EST) via the following poll: http://events.embark.com/event/harvard/mba/RegisterAndReserve.asp?FORMSTATE=1&EVID=22728

We hope you will be able to join us!

> MBA Admissions

This email went out to both domestic and international applicants who had applied in round one. Applicants with and without interview invites received the mail. Despite continued speculation in the BW Boards, this letter looks to be a fairly straightforward marketing exercise, albeit oddly timed.

While the school’s aim is to market the program and allow applicants to hear from current students, many participants in the conference call may be somewhat distracted by worries about interview invitations or pending admissions decisions. Despite these issues, we certainly approve of the effort on the committee’s part to be more transparent and to reach out to the applicant pool.

Share